[1]王新文,易雨婕.国家考古遗址公园规划实施效果评估研究——以汉长安城未央宫为例[J].西安建筑科技大学学报(自然科学版),2023,55(05):720-728.[doi:10.15986/j.1006-7930.2023.05.011]
　WANG Xinwen,YI Yujie.Study on evaluation of implementation effect of national archaeological site park planning：Taking Weiyang Palace in Han Chang′an City as an example[J].J. Xi’an Univ. of Arch. & Tech.(Natural Science Edition),2023,55(05):720-728.[doi:10.15986/j.1006-7930.2023.05.011]
点击复制

国家考古遗址公园规划实施效果评估研究——以汉长安城未央宫为例()
分享到：

西安建筑科技大学学报（自然科学版）[ISSN:1006-7930/CN:61-1295/TU]

卷:
55
期数:
2023年05期
页码:
720-728
栏目:
出版日期:
2023-10-28

文章信息/Info

Title:
Study on evaluation of implementation effect of national archaeological site park planning：Taking Weiyang Palace in Han Chang′an City as an example
文章编号:
1006-7930(2023)05-0720-09
作者:
王新文1; 易雨婕2
（1.西安建筑科技大学 建筑学院 , 陕西 西安 710055； 2.福州市规划设计研究院集团有限公司 国土空间规划设计院，福建 福州 350000）
Author(s):
WANG Xinwen1;  YI Yujie2
（1.Schoo1 of Architecture, Xi′an Univ.of Arch.& Tech., Xi′an 710055, China; 2.National Territory Spatial Planning and Design Institute, Fuzhou Planning & Design Research lnstitute Group Co., Ltd., Fuzhou 350000, China）
关键词:
国家考古遗址公园; 规划实施效果评估; 汉长安城未央宫遗址
Keywords:
archaeological site park;  evaluation of planning and implementation effects;  Weiyang Palace site of Han Chang′an City
分类号:
TU98
DOI:
10.15986/j.1006-7930.2023.05.011
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
国家考古遗址公园经十余年发展已进入规范化发展新阶段，基于规划学科发展及未来国家考古遗址公园高质量发展的需求，通过对考古遗址公园规划属性及内容的总结反思，以汉长安城未央宫国家考古遗址公园为例，从“效力+效用”的评估视角，从实施导向、责任导向和权益导向出发，尝试构建包含空间落实、资源维护、公众满意度三个层次、五个步骤在内的考古遗址公园规划实施效果评估方法体系并实践应用，进而分析总结提出完善动态规划编制体系及开展规划实施机制和规划实施影响评估等方面的结论与建议，以期推动考古遗址公园可持续发展.
Abstract:
The National Archaeological Site Park has entered a new stage of standardized development after more than ten years of development. Based on the development of the planning discipline and the future needs of highquality development of national archaeological site parks, this study summarizes and reflects on the attributes and contents of archaeological site park planning. Taking Weiyang Palace National Archaeological Site Park in Chang′an City of Han Dynasty as an example, from the perspective of “effectiveness+utility”, starting from the implementation orientation, responsibility orientation, and equity orientation, this study tries to construct an evaluation method system of the implementation effect of archaeological site park planning, which includes three levels and five steps of space implementation, resource maintenance and public satisfaction, and applies it in practice. Then it analyzes and summarizes the conclusions and suggestions on improving the dynamic planning system and carrying out the planning implementation mechanism and planning implementation impact assessment, in order to promote the sustainable development of archaeological site parks.

参考文献/References:

［1］国家文物局. 国家考古遗址公园发展报告［EB/OL］. ［2019-04-20］.
  State Administration of Cultural Heritage. National archaeological site park development report ［EB/OL］. ［2019-04-20］.
［2］王新文,张沛,张中华.城市更新视域下大明宫遗址区空间生产实践检讨及优化策略研究［J］.城市发展研究,2017,24(2):125-128.
  WANG Xinwen, ZHANG Pei, ZHANG Zhonghua. A review of spatial production practices and optimization strategies of Daminggong site area under the perspective of urban renewal［J］. Urban Development Research,2017,24(2):125-128.
［3］孙施文,周宇.城市规划实施评价的理论与方法［J］.城市规划汇刊,2003(2):15-20,27-95.
  SUN Shiwen, Zhou Yu.Theory and methods of urban planning implementation evaluation［J］. Journal of Urban Planning,2003(2):15-20,27-95.
［4］苏世亮,吕再扬,王伟,等.国土空间规划实施评估：概念框架与指标体系构建［J］.地理信息世界,2019,26(4):20-23.
  SU Shiliang, LU Zaiyang, WANG Wei, et al. Land spatial planning implementation assessment: conceptual framework and indicator system construction［J］. Geoinformation World,2019,26(4):20-23.
［5］TALEN E. Do plans get implemented：A review of evaluation in planning［J］.Journal of Planning literature,1996，10(3):248一259.
［6］林立伟,沈山,江国逊.中国城市规划实施评估研究进展［J］.规划师,2010,26(3):14-18.
  LIN LiWei, SHEN Shang, JIANG GuoXun. Progress of urban planning implementation assessment in China［J］. Planner,2010,26(3):14-18.
［7］何灵聪.基于动态维护的城市总体规划实施评估方法和机制研究［J］.规划师,2013,29(6):18-23.
  HE Lingcong. Research on the method and mechanism of urban master plan implementation assessment based on dynamic maintenance［J］. Planner,2013,29(6):18-23.
［8］周国艳.城市规划实施有效性评价:从关注结果转向关注过程的动态监控［J］.规划师,2013,29(6):24-28.
  ZHOU Guoyan. Evaluation of urban planning implementation effectiveness:from focusing on results to dynamic monitoring of the process［J］. Planner,2013,29(6):24-28.
［9］廖茂羽,罗震东.城市总体规划实施评估的方法体系与研究进展［J］.上海城市规划,2015(1):82-88.
  LIAO Maoyu, LUO Zhendong. Methodological system and research progress of urban master plan implementation assessment［J］. Shanghai Urban Planning,2015(1):82-88.
［10］庄优波.风景名胜区总体规划实施评价初探［C］//中国风景园林学会2013年会论文集（上册）.北京：中国建筑工业出版社,2013:244-248.
  ZHUANG Youbo. A preliminary study on the evaluation of the implementation of the master plan of scenic spots ［C］// Proceedings of the 2013 Annual Conference of the Chinese Society of Landscape Architecture (Vol. 1).Beijing: China Architecture & Building Press, 2013:244-248.
［11］李宁汀,石春晖,宋峰,等.风景名胜区总体规划实施评估研究以杭州西湖风景名胜区为例［J］.城市发展研究,2018,25(6):55-63.
  LI Ningting, SHI Chunhui, SONG Feng, et al. Study on the evaluation of the implementation of the master plan of scenic spotstaking Hangzhou West Lake scenic spot as an example［J］. Urban Development Research,2018,25(6):55-63.
［12］董文丽,李王鸣.历史文化名城保护规划实施评价研究综述［J］.华中建筑,2018,36(1):1-5.
  DONG Wenli, LI Wangming. A review of research on the implementation evaluation of historical and cultural city protection planning［J］. Huazhong Architecture,2018,36(1):1-5.
［13］张峻溪. 传统村落保护发展规划实施效果评估［D］.合肥: 安徽建筑大学,2019.
  ZHANG Junxi. Evaluation of the implementation effect of traditional village protection and development plan ［D］. Hefei: Anhui University of Architecture,2019.
［14］周俭,葛岩,张恺,等.历史文化风貌区保护规划实施评估类型方法研究与实践：以上海衡山路复兴路历史文化风貌区为例［J］.城市规划学刊,2021(4):26-34.
  ZHOU Jian, GE Yan, ZHANG Kai, et al. Research and practice on the type of evaluation method for the implementation of conservation planning in historical and cultural landscape areas: the example of Hengshan Road-Fuxing Road historical and cultural landscape area in Shanghai［J］. Journal of Urban Planning,2021(4):26-34.
［15］HOCKINGS M, STOLTON S, LEVERINGTON F. Evaluating Effectiveness: A Framework for Assessing Management Effectiveness of Protected Areas( 2nd ed). IUCN and Cambridge, Switzerland and UK: 2006.
［16］贾丽奇. 风景名胜区视野下的世界遗产缓冲区规划及实施机制研究［D］.北京：清华大学,2015.
  JIA Liqi. Research on the Planning and Implementation Mechanism of World Heritage Buffer Zone in the Perspective of Scenic Area［D］. Beijing: Tsinghua University,2015.
［17］唐凯.开展规划评估,促进规划改革［J］.城市规划,2011, 35(11):9-10.
  TANG Kai. Carrying out planning evaluation and promoting planning reform［J］. Urban planning, 2011, 35(11):9-10.
［18］刘成哲.城市总体规划动态实施评估体系研究［D］.天津: 天津大学,2013.
  LIU Chengzhe. Research on dynamic implementation assessment system of urban master plan ［D］. Tianjin: Tianjin University, 2013.
［19］周珂,吴斐琼,王剑. 保护规划实施评估方法的实例探索——上海市历史文化风貌区保护规划实施评估:以衡复风貌区实践为例［J］. 城乡规划, 2017, (2): 94-104.
  ZHOU Ke, WU Feiqiong, WANG Jian. An example exploration of conservation planning implementation assessment methods--Implementation assessment of conservation planning in Shanghai′s historical and cultural landscape areas:An example of practice in Hengfu Landscape District［J］. Urban and rural planning, 2017, (2): 94-104.
［20］张沛,徐云龙,杨露. 风景名胜区总体规划实施评估指标体系建构初探［J］.建筑与文化,2017(2):93-95.
  ZHANG Pei, XU Yunlong, YANG Lu. A preliminary investigation on the construction of index system for assessing the implementation of master plan of scenic spots［J］. Architecture and Culture,2017(2):93-95.
［21］TALEN E. After the plans: Methods to evaluate the implementation success of plans［J］. Journal of Planning Education and Research,1996, 6(2): 79-91.
［22］周海东. 人本视角下的历史文化名镇保护规划实施评估体系研究——以周庄古镇为例［J］. 中国名城, 2021, 35(5): 56-65.
  ZHOU Haidong. Research on the implementation evaluation system of historical and cultural town conservation planning from a human-oriented perspective: the example of Zhouzhuang ancient town［J］. China Famous Towns, 2021, 35(5): 56-65.
［23］兰泽青,岳邦瑞,王敬儒.景观生态规划中的空间机制分析方法与应用途径［J］.西安建筑科技大学学报(自然科学版),2022,54(1):120-126.
  LAN Zeqing, YUE Bangrui, WANG Jingru. Spatial mechanism analysis methods and application approaches in landscape ecological planning［J］. Journal of Xi′an University of Architecture and Technology (Natural Science Edition),2022,54(1):120-126.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
收稿日期:2022-09-08修回日期:2023-08-15
基金项目:国家社科基金项目（23BKG039）
第一作者:王新文 (1974—)，男，博士，副教授，硕士生导师，主要研究城乡历史文化遗产保护规划.E-mail:284917006@qq.com
通信作者:易雨婕 (1995—)，女，硕士，助理工程师，主要研究城乡历史文化遗产保护规划.E-mail:947263450@qq.com
更新日期/Last Update: 2023-11-03